Overwatch --- Overall Game of the Year
Best PC Games of 2016:
- Overwatch --- PC GOTY
- Battlefield 1
- Devil Daggers
- DOOM
- Epistory: Typing Chronicles
- Firewatch
- Hyper Light Drifter
- INSIDE
- King's Quest
- Owlboy
- Stardew Valley
- Stephen's Sausage Roll
- Superhot
- The Witness
- World of Warcraft: Legion
- XCOM 2
Best PS4 Games of 2016:
- Uncharted 4: A Thief's End --- PS4 GOTY
- The Witness
- Dark Souls III
- Ratchet & Clank
- HITMAN
- ABZU
- Rez Infinite
- RIGS: Mechanized Combat League
- I Am Setsuna
- Gravity Rush Remastered
- Battleborn
- Destiny: Rise of Iron
- World of Final Fantasy
- INSIDE
- The Last Guardian
Best Xbox One Games of 2016:
- Dark Souls III --- Xbox One GOTY
- Battleborn
- Destiny: Rise of Iron
- Forza Horizon 3
- Gears of War 4
- INSIDE
- Killer Instinct: Season 3
- Quantum Break
- Raiden V
- Rocket League
- Superhot
- Unravel
- The Witness
Best VR Games of 2016:
- Keep Talking and Nobody Explodes --- VR GOTY
- EVE: Valkyrie
- Rez Infinite
- Adr1ft
- The Climb
- Raw Data
- The Gallery: Call of Starseed
- Space Pirate Trainer
Best Mobile Games of 2016:
- Severed --- Mobile Game GOTY
- The Bug Butcher
- Deus Ex GO
- Hearthstone: One Night in Karazhan
- Mobius Final Fantasy
- Pokemon Go
Best Wii U Games of 2016:
- Tokyo Mirage Sessions FE --- Wii U GOTY
- Pokken Tournament
- Paper Mario: Color Splash
- The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess HD
- Star Fox Zero
Best 3DS Games of 2016:
- Bravely Second: End Layer
- Fire Emblem Fates
- Hyrule Warriors Legends
- Kirby: Planet Robobot
- Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam
- Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Spirit of Justice
- Pokemon Sun and Moon
- Rhythm Heaven Megamix
- Yo-Kai Watch 2
Best PS Vita Games of 2016:
- Zero Escape: Zero Time Dilemma --- PS Vita GOTY
- Severed
- Odin Sphere: Leifthrasir
- World of Final Fantasy
Source: https://www.destructoid.com/destructoid-s-award-for-overall-best-game-of-2016-goes-to--407109.phtml